Friday, March 22, 2013

The Incoherence of the Conservative Christian Position


While watching “Wife Swap” last night I was disturbed and frustrated by the homophobic attitude of the “Christian” family.  Now, you might argue that the basis of that sentence is, in itself, a contradiction.  After all, it is a reality show and not something that anyone should look to for a lesson in spirituality, morality, or humanity.  Being that it’s main function is to entertain us, do we really need to take it that seriously?  But when the children argued that a person can choose not to be gay just like someone can choose not to be a murderer, I had to take it seriously.  Did we really just compare being gay to being a killer?  I’m surrounded by so many open-hearted and open minded people that sometimes I get startled when I see such blind ignorance.  And it’s frustrating to me when people hide behind religion and refuse to grow or challenge themselves to learn.
The leaders of the Christian right don't seem interested in acknowledging the complexities that surround the issue of homosexuality. They have glossed over the difficult questions and gone straight for the emotional jugular, talking about family values, the future of our children, and the decline of our nation, in order to rally an American moral majority behind them. But once again, what they are really concerned about is pushing their Christian moral agenda because, let's face it, they don't really care what the majority of Americans think.

Let's go back to the question of whether homosexuality is a choice. Let's say, for the sake of argument, that Christians are right in believing that it is a choice, so that once same-sex marriage is legally approved in society, numerous people begin converting to the "gay lifestyle" and the number of same-sex marriages begin to rival that of heterosexual marriages. What if homosexuals were to manage a moral majority that began to view heterosexuality as unnatural? Or perhaps more realistically, a majority that viewed the church's religious prohibition against same-sex marriage as illegal discrimination? Imagine how it would be for them as a Christian right religious community to have to fight for their civil liberty against such an onslaught. That is exactly the position they have put the gay community in when they rally public opinion against their right to marry.

Now let me settle here and now the issue of whether or not a church should have the right to refuse to perform marriages for same sex couples.  The answer is a resounding “YES”.  That is the whole problem with this issue.  It’s a matter of civil rights.  Some churches will not perform a marriage for someone unless they are members of that church.  Is that discrimination?  No.   A church and it’s members should have the freedom to worship and follow the tenets of that religion as they see fit.  And that is exactly how far the government and our churches should mix.  We guarantee the right to Freedom of Religion and that should be the extent of it.  The problem is we don't feel the need to go to such lengths to safeguard our religious freedom because we smugly take for granted that it will always be there. Such complacency has blinded us from seeing how we actually threaten religious freedom when people dismiss gay rights on the grounds that homosexuals choose their life.

Are Christians afraid that supporting same-sex marriage will send a message to the gay community that Christians approve of homosexuality? Well, believe me, the gay community is under no such delusion. For years they have listened to arguments against homosexuality ad nauseam and can even quote all the pertinent Bible verses back by heart.  Tell me this, have you read Leviticus lately?  Do you associate with people with tattoos or pierced ears?  Shame on you.  Do you own any clothing that is made with two different fabrics?  Oopsie, that’s in there too.  Guess you aren't the Christian you thought you were after all. 
If the Christian community so concerned about the message being sent, why not look at it as sending a message that they approve of committed relationships and sexual responsibility? Aren't these the values worth fighting for and worth encouraging?

It is high time that we grow up and learn to play fair. Freedom for us means freedom for someone else too, even our fellow Americans in the gay and lesbian community. Is that too high a price to pay? Of course not. Civil liberties is what gives us the freedom to pursue our moral convictions in this country in the first place. It is what guarantees a future for ourselves and our children in which we will be able to practice our religious beliefs free of harassment and fear.

I’ll close with two of my favorite quotes from Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.  In the end, when I see people speaking out of fear and ignorance, I can’t be angry.  I just have to hope that their hearts and minds are opened to love.  There was a point in the history of this country when people stood up for civil rights even when it wasn’t popular or easy.  And we will keep standing and keep fighting until we really are all treated as equally as we are created.

“Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that.” ~ Martin Luther King, Jr.

“Human progress is neither automatic nor inevitable... Every step toward the goal of justice requires sacrifice, suffering, and struggle; the tireless exertions and passionate concern of dedicated individuals.” ~ Martin Luther King, Jr. 

No comments:

Post a Comment